The Price of Bread: Grain Markets and Hard Times

From the Adam Stark Newsbooks 1821–1841

Market reports for the Tuesday grain market at Gainsborough were sent to the Stamford Mercury by Adam Stark, the bookseller and correspondent for the paper. These reports provide a valuable insight into the state of the harvest and the weather, as well as the ability of the poor to afford to eat bread and the willingness of the holders of the grain to sell.

For the years 1821-27 there are 195 entries for the market prices of the several grains. These entries are the longest and most regular series of reports in the newsbooks for these years of great fluctuation in the price of English grain after the Napoleonic Wars. Over the seven years the price of wheat at Gainsborough fluctuated between below 30s. a quarter to over 70s. a quarter. This was a great difference to a poor family between eating and not eating.

The Gainsborough Corn Market

The Tuesday market at Gainsborough was one of the principal grain markets in the East Midlands. Hundreds of quarters of wheat changed hands on some market days, and on one occasion in November 1824 more than 1,000 quarters of barley were sold at an advance of about a shilling a quarter. Many hundreds of quarters of wheat, barley, oats, beans and peas were sold at the market on other days.

Reports by Stark on the grain markets at Gainsborough were frequently printed in the Mercury and other papers. He opens with a few lines on the supply (‘a liberal supply’ or ‘a short supply’), which way prices were going (‘on the advance’ or ‘at a decline’) and how buyers and sellers were behaving (‘brisk’, ‘flat’, ‘dull in the extreme’). Then come the figures for each grain: the number of quarters sold, their total value in pounds, shillings and pence, and the average price per quarter.

The five grains mentioned most frequently in the market reports were wheat, barley, oats, rye and beans. Wheat was the bread grain and therefore the most important to track. Barley was used for malting, and there were many brewers and maltsters in the Gainsborough area. Oats were used for horses and also by the poor for human consumption. Rye was a cheaper bread grain than wheat, and beans were used for animal feed and also by the poor.

A considerable deal of business was done this day in all sorts of grain and wheat, although bearing the same average as last week is rather better; barley is also about 1/6 higher and oats as well as beans and peas may all be quoted at better prices.

Wheat 521 qrs £1570.3 average 60/3. Barley 301 qrs £642.19 average 42/7. Oats 42 qrs £50.10 average 24/-. Beans 60 qrs £149.10 average 49/10.

Source: Adam Stark Newsbooks, October 1824

The Sandars family, the Gainsborough corn merchants, who were also canal promoters, are mentioned frequently in the newsbooks. These entries would have been of interest to other traders in the town, such as millers, maltsters and dealers, as much of the grain sold at the Tuesday market would have been transported by water down the Trent to Hull for shipment to London and the north of the country. The prices of the wheat, given in the table below, are the average prices per quarter as given in the market returns for Gainsborough.

Twenty-One Years of Wheat Prices

These years were of particular hardship and importance in the history of the grain trade.

Year Wheat (s/qr) Market Conditions
1821 38 Relatively stable; post-war prices settling
1822 42 Flat spring market; ‘barley unsaleable’ in May
1823 51 Rising through the year; brisk spring demand
1824 65 Sharp rise; brisk November markets, barley over 1,000 qrs at one sale
1825 62–70+ Peak prices; August entries record 70s-72s; farmers withholding
1826 55 Declining from highs; heavy supply, ‘dull in the extreme’
1827 54 Further decline; markets settling

Prices were highly variable throughout a single year as well as from one year to the next. For example, in October 1822 wheat was selling at as low as 27s. per quarter, whilst in January 1825 wheat was selling at as high as 72s. per quarter. 27s. per quarter would purchase bread for a month for a laboring family, whilst 72s. per quarter would purchase bread for a month for a laboring family. The Corn Law of 1815 had prohibited the importation of foreign wheat until the price of English wheat rose to 80 shillings a quarter, in order to protect the interests of English landowners and farmers after the Napoleonic Wars.

The Corn Laws and Their Shadow

In practice this meant that, while prices were rising, foreign grain could not be brought in to help to lower the price until it had reached extreme levels.

The market price of wheat in Gainsborough did not reach 80s. a quarter during the period of Stark’s reporting, but it came close in 1825. That August he wrote that ‘from the continuance of wet weather our market advanced 7/- per quarter on fine wheats’. A rise of seven shillings in one week reflected worry about the harvest, and the fact that no imports could come in to ease it. The Corn Laws, of 1815, were the subject of much debate in the 1820s as the free trade views of the economist Ricardo and the politician Cobden gained ground. In 1828 the fixed price at which foreign grain could be imported was replaced by a sliding scale. This was to be retained until the Corn Laws were finally repealed in 1846.

The cost of bread was of vital importance to the poor of Gainsborough and the surrounding villages. In many instances, the price of a quartern loaf was equal to a man’s weekly wages. In the years of high prices for wheat, the number of committals for vagrancy at the Petty Sessions was very high.

The Language of the Market

The reports written by Stark are also of interest because they are written by a bookseller who is reporting on the grain trade of a small town. His reports are of interest because they are more than a list of figures. They are reports of a grain trader who is writing for other traders, and they reflect the mood of the grain trade as well as the prices.

For markets with short supply and rising prices, Stark used words like ‘brisk’, ‘wheat in demand’ and ‘farmers ‘wishing for much higher prices’: sellers with the upper hand’. When supply exceeded demand for grain, Stark used words like ‘flat’, ‘dull’, ‘heavy’ for markets, ‘grain ‘remained unsold at the close of the market’’ for the various grains and ‘buyers stayed away’ for prices ‘suffered a small declension’.

Our market this day was very flat and very little business done. Wheat’s are a trifle better but Oats are about 4d lower than last week. In Beans little was done and Barley’s were unsaleable.

Source: Adam Stark Newsbooks, May 1822

The reports of ‘unsaleable’ barley in May 1822 would indicate that the maltsters had stopped buying and therefore the trade of the brewers and other malting traders had come to a halt. A market which was ‘flat’ could recover in the following week but when the main grains were ‘remained unsold at the close’, trade had ceased altogether and the farmers took their samples home.

There were also reports of farmers withholding grain in the hope of higher prices. In January 1825, for example, Stark noted that farmers were still withholding wheat, which was then selling at near 70 shillings a quarter. He wrote: ‘In Barley not much business done, the farmers wishing for much higher prices than those of this day week for such as were fit for malting.’ A farmer with grain in the barn who expected prices to keep rising would sensibly wait, and buyers who expected the same would wait too. News of the harvest elsewhere, of the weather to come and of what the ships were bringing into Hull counted for as much as the grain itself.

Harvest Anxiety: Weather and the Crop

No account of the grain trade can be complete without some reference to the weather. Stark’s reports do not always include an explanation of the price changes, but where they do, they almost invariably refer to the farming year, to the size of the harvest, to the quality of the grain in the barn, and to the condition of the new crop on the ground.

In September 1825, a year of high prices, Stark noted that ‘old wheat obtained more money owing to the samples of new wheat being generally damp and not in condition for grinding.’ newly harvested wheat was too wet to mill and therefore millers who were not prepared to wait for it to dry were paying extra for the old wheat of the previous year’s harvest.

The summer of 1825 was a wet one, with reports of grain being too wet to mill in August and September. In August: ‘from the continuance of wet weather our market advanced 7/- per quarter on fine wheats.’ In late August: ‘the wheat market was dull and not many buyers, several samples of new offered which obtained from 69/- to 72/-.’ The harvest was in and the grain was reaching market, but the quality was patchy, and fear of a poor crop kept prices up even with the grain there to be bought.

From the continuance of wet weather our market advanced 7/- per quarter on fine wheats. Beans were much enquired after and may be quoted 1/- higher. Wheat 347 qrs £1228.7 average 70/9.

Source: Adam Stark Newsbooks, August 1825 (a rise of seven shillings a quarter in a single week)

In 1826 the price of wheat fell below the high level of the previous year. In February of that year Stark reported that, ‘Heavy as possible’ (‘the supply of all kinds of grain was very great, the sale heavy as possible even at the reduction on wheat 3/- per quarter and barley 2/- to 3/- per quarter.’) on the grain market, there were more sellers than buyers. The farmers who had withheld their grain from the market in the expectation of higher prices during the previous year were now bringing it to market in large quantities, with the result that the scarcity had been replaced by a glut.

What the Price Meant: Bread, Wages and Poverty

The reports written by Stark for the Mercury were business news written for the traders in a town. He did not explicitly mention how the prices would affect the ordinary person. However, the readers of 1825 would have had some idea of how much bread would cost for a laborer in Lincolnshire in the 1820s.

A laboring family in Lincolnshire in the 1820s would have earned between £8 and £12 a year. Thus, in 1825, the price of a quarter of wheat (28 lbs of flour or enough for a family’s bread for a month) would have been between 5 and 9 weeks’ wages. The poor of the town would have bought their flour by the stone, but even so, the price of bread in 1825 would have taken up a large proportion of their income. In the winter of 1824–25, Stark noted the price of wheat rising on a weekly basis, from 60s. to 68s., to 70s. and finally to 72s. a quarter. It was a very hard winter for the poor of Gainsborough.

As for the poor, Stark never mentions them in the market reports. They were not the sort of people for whom he was writing. He was writing for the merchants and farmers of Gainsborough and the propertied classes who read the Mercury. The rest of the newsbooks are full of the deaths of the poor, the committals of the poor to Kirton for vagrancy, the bastardy orders against the poor, the inquests on the poor, the reports of the poor being committed for begging, the burials of the poor from the workhouse. These are the sort of things that the newsbooks report in the same pages as the grain prices.

There is one entry from January 1824 which is not a market report but from the same era. Stark recorded ‘as a matter of curiosity as well as shewing the very great improvement in the value of life at least in this county’ that in the parish of Scotter there had been only nine burials in the previous year, four of them infants, the rest aged 88, 83, 77, 72 and 58. This was a sign of long life and good health, and Stark said nothing about what it might tell us about grain prices and survival. In the 1820s, though, the link between a bad harvest and the burial register was still close enough to measure.

Going West: A Letter from Canada

The newsbooks don’t make it clear why the market entries stop in 1827. Stark continued to send pieces to the Mercury until 1841, but after that date the detailed weekly reports became less frequent. By the late 1830s, the corn market was changing, with the railways beginning to reshape the regional grain trade and the battle over the Corn Laws intensifying until their repeal in 1846.

One entry from July 1835 is of some interest as it shows how the conditions of the farming year in the 1820s had led to the emigration of people from the county of Lincolnshire to North America. Stark printed ‘the following extract of a letter from Woolwich, Upper Canada, to his friends at Scotton’. The writer had left Lincolnshire for North America and was telling his family what he had found. He had caught the fever and ague within a month of his arrival, but had recovered after taking medicine. He had also bought 132 dollars’ worth of land and was very pleased with the situation of the land he had bought.

I had the misfortune to catch the fever and ague before I had been in America a month but by taking medicine I got clear of it.

We have bought a lot of land for 132 dollars and we have found it very well situated. The land is good and the country is in a thriving state.

Source: Extract from a letter, Woolwich, Upper Canada, reproduced in Adam Stark Newsbooks, July 1835

The Scotton man had emigrated from a county where the price of grain could fluctuate by 40s. in a year, and where the Corn Laws were in force to protect the interests of the farmers and keep the price of bread high, and where the wages of the farm laborers had not increased in proportion to the prices of the post-war period. He was now in a country where he could purchase land for a fixed price, and where the price of bread was not subject to the same fluctuations as in the Tuesday market at Gainsborough. He mentioned the fever and ague which he had contracted, but seemed to have recovered from it within a month.

The Market and the Town

On the page, Adam Stark’s 195 market price entries are just columns of figures: quarters, pounds, shillings, pence, averages. Read them alongside everything else he recorded over twenty-one years (the accidents, the crime, the deaths, the weather, the public health crises) and they become a week-by-week record of the town’s economy, the thing on which almost everything else depended.

Gainsborough was a market town. Its life revolved around the Tuesday market, the wharf, the corn merchants and the millers. When wheat was at 70 shillings the town was anxious and the poor went hungry. When the market was ‘brisk’ and ‘every article on the advance’, the merchants did well and the Trent carried another cargo to Hull. Stark’s entries for the Mercury did not offer opinions on the economy. They reported what the market had done, accurately, for readers who needed to know.

These short pieces of prose, preceding each week’s figures, give us what the numbers cannot: the farmer holding his grain through a wet summer; the flat Tuesday when nobody was buying; the brisk early November when 1,200 quarters of barley changed hands and everything was on the advance. Stark wrote these things down because they were ordinary, ordinary enough to send to the paper every week for seven years. That is exactly why they are so useful now.

Sources

This article was written using the Adam Stark Newsbooks 1821–1841, transcribed by Paul Kemp and Andrew Birkitt, 2009, held by Gainsborough Heritage Centre. The 195 Market Price entries are searchable in the Adam Stark Newsbooks Database, including the weekly grain returns for wheat, barley, oats, rye, and beans. Background on the Corn Laws is taken from standard historical sources on early nineteenth-century British agricultural policy.

Author

Post a comment